← Discussions

mothproof

I still think some of you are looking at the wrong part.

798 points · 0 posts · 30 replies

Posts · 0

Replies · 30

In Big Zoo · why does the zoo argument end with giraffes?

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

I came back to this because the other threads keep treating the zoo as a neutral place to check the claim. That is the assumption being argued over here. Sending someone back to the enclosure does not answer it.

9points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · anybody still here from the old threads?

In Flat Giraffers · where are the group admins?

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

People keep mixing up moth and me. I don't have another account.

10points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · both of the recordings are still there

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

A playback timestamp is not the date somebody uploaded the file. Keep both if either is important.

7points
ReplyLink

In Paper Trails · same exhibition. three weeks apart

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

Replying to rustred

I still don't see anything saying which one went in the enclosure.

16points
ReplyLink

In Paper Trails · the pattern deserves its own argument

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

Replying to rustred

It is a display figure. People make those.

8points
ReplyLink

In Big Zoo · Why were the vet and the electrician booked together?

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

Replying to wrenched

Because there were two jobs.

0points
ReplyLink

In Paper Trails · anyone got the full version of this picture

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

Found the page. Davenhall Chronicle, 22 June 1957. The right-hand side is there.

62points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · [removed]

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

The question about the picture is in the older thread. Leave people's details out of this.

4points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · why does the same sort of neck get a different explanation?

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

There is another jump here. A neck being capable of a movement and an animal using that movement to hide are separate claims. Which one is the alleged omission?

12points
ReplyLink

In Big Zoo · the part about everyone taking photographs

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

I don’t agree with its conclusion. But I know exactly the crowd it means.

6points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · Same patch, different decade

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

You've picked one patch. The three little ones beside it don't match.

0points
ReplyLink

In Big Zoo · that’s my mum talking. she wasn’t there that day.

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

The old link is unavailable. I heard it on Tuesday, before anybody starts saying it was always a dead player.

3points
ReplyLink

In Big Zoo · that’s my mum talking. she wasn’t there that day.

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

Replying to rustred

There could be a fixed camera on the building. You can't get its position exactly from one frame

14points
ReplyLink

In Side Quests · whoever had this before me went through it with a pen

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

Maybe they started crossing something out and gave up

9points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · three zoos. the same sneeze.

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

Replying to flatlander

When it is an animal doing it. You are assuming the thing you're trying to prove

11points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · three zoos. the same sneeze.

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

Animals have reflexes. People put a hand up when they cough. We don't all download it from the same place

41points
ReplyLink

In Big Zoo · the park shut in 1998. this was filmed last week.

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

Does somebody else use the land now?

22points
ReplyLink

In Paper Trails · it was under lost animals in the older edition

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

If people thought it was gone and then somebody exhibited one, of course the next edition would change

25points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · he was seventeen when i was in primary school

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

This site is ridiculous sometimes. Three leaflets get an age wrong and suddenly it's a robot.

5points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · he was seventeen when i was in primary school

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

Replying to brickwork

Then they could have reused the photograph

12points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · he was seventeen when i was in primary school

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

It could be another animal with the same name

20points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · the little book is up

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

I've read the sample. I disagree with most of it but at least it doesn't stop in the middle of the claim.

5points
ReplyLink

In Big Zoo · they were writing down conversations at the gardens

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

Replying to rustred

It doesn't say there was a sound recording. Somebody may have been listening and writing

11points
ReplyLink

In Paper Trails · for everyone saying i was making it up, i got my grandpa to find the paper and did a scan lol he was not happy

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

Replying to marl

Or it was the exhibition figure they told the reporter about

15points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · does anybody have the one before they put the skin on

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

Post them next to each other when you find them. These descriptions could be several things

6points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · the mouth moves after the head has stopped

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

My jaw also moves without my whole head moving

19points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · i think giraffes actually aren't real.

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

Replying to teaspoon

They are called ossicones. Naming them is not an explanation of their use.

39points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · i think giraffes actually aren't real.

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

Replying to windowseat

You started with distance from the head and you've moved to height from the ground. Which measurement would let you change your mind?

58points
ReplyLink

In Flat Giraffers · i think giraffes actually aren't real.

mothproof
Collapse or expand reply by mothproof

You have ruled out every possible observation before asking for observations. An animal doesn't become imaginary because somebody put a fence around it.

303points
ReplyLink

Experience controls